Might be skipping steps based on his trials with the carve bit. Belts too lose? GT2 pulley grub/set screws not fully seated? Stepper motor connection intermittent? Only one stepper motor active on one of the axes (this has happened me)?
Last week I went back and used Blue Loctite on my GT2 set screws after I was sure things were working - and every other set screw was starting to back out after only a few hours of use.
Belts to tight will make it move jerky. The stepper motors are 76oz, 4.75 pounds. Make sure your 2 X belts and 2 Y belts are the exact same length and adjust tension with the zip tie. Just snug. I used little pliers to set all the bends in the zip ties.